Finding the right wish journal refill pages can be challenging, especially with so many options that differ in paper quality, size, and style. The Traveler Notebook Refills Insert – A5 Ruled stands out as the best overall pick for its balanced quality and versatility. For those seeking a more minimalist experience, the Wanderings A5 Blank Travelers Notebook Insert offers a clean slate for creative wishes. The main tradeoffs involve balancing budget with paper quality and how well the refill fits your specific journal system. Keep reading for a detailed comparison to help you make the best choice for your wish journaling goals.
Turn your quiet moments into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
Key Takeaways
- Refill size and compatibility are critical—ensure the pages fit your journal system perfectly.
- Paper quality varies significantly; thicker, 120gsm+ paper reduces bleed-through for pens and markers.
- Lined pages are more versatile for wish writing, but blank inserts suit more creative or sketch-based wishes.
- Quantity and price per sheet influence value—more pages often mean better savings, but check for quality.
- Refill options with additional features like built-in bookmarks or thicker paper cater to specific needs.
| wish journal refill page | Size | Pages |
|---|---|---|
| Traveler Notebook Refills Inse | A5 | 200 |
| Traveler Notebook Refills Inse | A5 | 200 |
| Wanderings A5 Lined Travelers | 5.5" x 8.3" | 240 lined pages |
| Zhanmai 5 Pack A5 Notebook Ins | 5.5 x 8.2 inches | — |
| Lined Refill Paper for Hardcov | 8.2" x 5.6" | — |
| Zhanmai 2 Pack A5 Refillable N | 5.5 x 8.2 inches | — |
| A5 Notebook Refill | 8.07" x 5.5" | 256 |
| SETTINI Refill Inserts for A5 | — | 192 |
| Moonster A5 Journal Inserts Li | 5.75" x 8.25" | — |
| Moonster A5 Lined Journal Refi | A5 | 192 |
| The Amazing Office Journal Ref | 5.5 x 8.125 inches | 200 pages |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Traveler Notebook Refills Insert – A5 Ruled Refill for Refillable Journals
This A5 ruled refill offers a balanced combination of eco-friendliness and practicality, making it an excellent choice for those who want a reliable, all-purpose refill for their refillable journals. Compared with the Zhanmai 5 Pack A5 Notebook Inserts, this option stands out for its neutral grey lines, which are easier on the eyes for daily writing or journaling. Its acid-free pages ensure longevity, but it’s limited to ruled pages, unlike blank or dotted alternatives. The lightweight design makes it ideal for travelers and daily note-takers who value portability but may be restrictive for artists needing blank pages. Its size compatibility with most refillable A5 journals ensures broad usability, though it doesn’t include a cover, requiring users to manage that separately.
Pros:- Compatible with most refillable A5 journals
- Eco-friendly and acid-free pages ensure longevity
- Lightweight and portable for travel or daily use
Cons:- Limited to A5 size journals, reducing flexibility
- No cover included, requiring separate purchase
Best for: People who need a reliable, versatile refill for their A5 journals that combines eco-friendliness with everyday practicality.
Not ideal for: Creative users who prefer sketching or doodling, as it only offers ruled pages and no blank or dotted options.
- Size:A5
- Pages:200
- Paper Type:Acid-Free, White
- Page Count:Both sides
- GSM:100 gsm
Our verdict“This refill is ideal for journalers seeking a dependable, eco-conscious option for note-taking and travel journaling.”
Traveler Notebook Refills Insert – A5 Blank Refill for Refillable Journals
This A5 blank refill is perfect for users who prioritize freedom of expression, offering 200 high-quality, acid-free pages suitable for both writing and sketching. Unlike the Wanderings A5 Lined Travelers Notebook Insert, which features lined pages, this product provides a blank surface that caters to artists and writers alike. Its lay-flat design enhances ease of use, but since it only offers blank pages, it may not satisfy those who prefer ruled lines for structure. The leather-bound cover adds a touch of elegance and durability, though it limits compatibility with non-leather-bound journals. Its lightweight build makes it highly portable, but it might not be suitable for those needing specific page formats like dotted or grid.
Pros:- Compatible with most A5 refillable journals
- High-quality, acid-free paper suitable for various mediums
- Lay-flat design for ease of drawing or writing on both sides
Cons:- Limited to blank pages, not suitable for structured note-taking
- May not fit journals with non-leather covers
Best for: Artists, doodlers, and note-takers who need a flexible refill for sketching and creative projects in their A5 journals.
Not ideal for: Users seeking lined or specialized formats, as it only provides blank pages and may not fit journals with different cover styles.
- Size:A5
- Pages:200
- Paper Type:Acid-Free, White
- Page Weight:100 gsm
- Cover:Leather-bound, Edged
Our verdict“This refill makes the most sense for creative users who need a versatile blank canvas for their journaling or sketching projects.”
Wanderings A5 Lined Travelers Notebook Insert / A5 Journal Refill, 3 Booklets, 240 Pages
This set of three A5 lined refills provides 240 pages of bleed-through resistant, cream-colored paper, making it an excellent choice for fountain pen users. Compared to the Zhanmai 5 Pack A5 Notebook Refills, these offer a higher GSM (120) and superior paper quality, ideal for those who prioritize smooth ink flow without feathering. The hand-sewn construction and rounded corners enhance durability and comfort during extended use, but the limited to lined pages might frustrate those who want more diverse formats. The set’s premium design makes it more suitable for serious writers or collectors, though the absence of blank or dotted options restricts flexibility for varied projects.
Pros:- Bleed-through resistant, high-quality paper
- Durable, hand-sewn construction with rounded corners
- Ideal for fountain pens and smooth writing experience
Cons:- Limited to lined pages, less flexible for sketches or bullet journaling
- No included cover or binding, just refills
Best for: Fountain pen users and writers seeking high-quality, durable refills for their A5 notebooks with a premium feel.
Not ideal for: Creative users needing blank or dotted pages, or those on a tight budget, as these are more expensive than basic refills.
- Size:5.5″ x 8.3″
- Pages:240 lined pages
- GSM:120 GSM
- Number of Booklets:3
- Sheets per Booklet:40
Our verdict“This set is best suited for fountain pen aficionados and those seeking a high-end, durable refill for structured journaling.”
Zhanmai 5 Pack A5 Notebook Inserts 5.5 x 8.2 inches, Ruled Journal Refill
This pack of five ruled A5 refills offers excellent value for those who need multiple inserts for daily writing, planning, or journaling. Its classic design and smooth paper make it suitable for a wide range of writing instruments, comparable to the Moonster A5 Journal Inserts Lined. While this pack provides ample pages—200 per notebook—the ruled format limits versatility for artistic or bullet journaling. The absence of a cover or special features means users must source their own protective cover, but the affordability makes it attractive for bulk purchases. It’s not the best choice for those seeking blank, dotted, or high-end premium paper, but it covers basic needs reliably.
Pros:- Five refill notebooks provide great value
- Ample 200 pages per refill for daily use
- Classic, elegant design suitable for various settings
Cons:- Limited to ruled pages, no blank or dotted options
- No cover included, requiring separate purchase
Best for: Budget-conscious journalers, students, and daily writers needing multiple inserts at a low cost.
Not ideal for: Artists or fountain pen enthusiasts who require bleed-through resistant or specialty paper, as this is standard ruled paper without extra features.
- Quantity:5 pieces
- Page count:200 pages / 100 sheets
- Size:5.5 x 8.2 inches
- Format:Ruled
Our verdict“This pack is ideal for users who want affordable, bulk refills for everyday journaling or planning without extra frills.”
Lined Refill Paper for Hardcover Leather Notebook, A5 Refill Page, 240 Pages
This refill set offers 240 pages of thick, ink-resistant cream white paper designed to fit refillable leather-bound A5 notebooks. It includes a ribbon bookmark, adding a touch of convenience for those who want a luxurious, premium refill. In comparison with the Wanderings A5 Lined Travelers Notebook Insert, which features a more delicate cream paper, this set emphasizes durability and a high-quality writing surface, especially suited for ink-heavy writing. Its eco-friendly materials and inclusion of bookmark make it attractive for serious journalers, but its size and refill-only nature limit use to specific leather journals. It’s less suitable for those needing flexible formats or non-A5 sizes.
Pros:- Thick, ink-resistant paper enhances writing quality
- Eco-friendly, recyclable materials make it sustainable
- Includes a ribbon bookmark for easy navigation
Cons:- Limited to A5 leather notebooks, reducing compatibility
- Refill-only product, not a complete journal
Best for: Leather journal owners and writers who value thick, ink-resistant paper for smooth, high-quality writing sessions.
Not ideal for: Users with non-A5 or non-leather journals, or those preferring blank or dotted pages, as this only offers lined, cream-colored paper.
- Page Count:240 pages
- Sheet Count:120 sheets
- Size:8.2″ x 5.6″
- Material:Cream white, eco-friendly
- Includes:Ribbon bookmark, protective card pages
Our verdict“This refill is best for leather journal owners seeking durable, premium-quality pages for smooth, ink-rich writing.”
Zhanmai 2 Pack A5 Refillable Notebook Inserts, 5.5 x 8.2 inches, 100 Sheets
This set of two A5 refillable inserts offers a generous 200 pages, making it ideal for daily journaling, planning, or note-taking. Compared to the Moonster A5 Lined Journal Refill, it provides more pages per refill, though it’s limited to ruled paper, which may not suit creative users seeking blank or grid options. The kraft paper enhances durability and a classic look, but the fixed format and slight size variations mean it might not fit all A5 notebooks perfectly. Its lightweight construction makes it perfect for travel and daily carry, though the absence of additional formats or paper types restricts versatility. This pick is best suited for users needing reliable, straightforward refill pages that are easy to carry and compatible with most A5 notebooks.
Pros:- Ample writing space with 200 sheets total
- Portable and lightweight for on-the-go use
- Elegant, timeless kraft paper design
Cons:- Limited to ruled format, no blank or grid options
- Refill only, not a standalone notebook
- May not fit all A5 notebooks if dimensions vary slightly
Best for: Travelers and daily journal users who prioritize portability and classic design.
Not ideal for: Creative professionals seeking blank or grid pages for sketches or detailed layouts.
- Quantity:2 pieces
- Size:5.5 x 8.2 inches
- Sheets:200 sheets / 100 sheets per insert
- Format:Ruled
- Material:Kraft paper
Our verdict“This refill set is ideal for users who want reliable, portable ruled pages with a classic aesthetic.”
A5 Notebook Refill – 256 Pages Lined Journal Insert for Study, Travel, Planners – Refillable A5 Planner or Diary – 8.07″ x 5.5″ – 1 Pack
This refill provides 256 pages of smooth, bleed-resistant paper, making it an excellent choice for students, professionals, or anyone who writes extensively. Compared to the Moonster A5 Lined Journal Refill, it offers more pages per pack, though it’s limited to a single pack size, which could be a downside for heavy users. Its compatibility with most A5 refillable notebooks and planners makes it highly versatile, perfect for daily journaling or detailed planning. The high-quality paper handles various pens without bleed-through, but the single size and pack limit might restrict flexibility for those needing multiple options. This refill makes the most sense for those seeking a high-volume, reliable writing surface at a reasonable price.
Pros:- High-quality, bleed-resistant paper
- Compatible with most A5 refillable notebooks
- Large 256-page capacity for long-term use
Cons:- Limited to one pack size, less flexible for bulk needs
- Only available in A5 size, not adaptable to larger notebooks
Best for: Students and professionals who need extensive writing capacity without sacrificing quality.
Not ideal for: Creative users who prefer blank or mixed-media pages or need multiple formats in one purchase.
- Pages:256
- Sheets:128
- Size:8.07″ x 5.5″
- Compatibility:Most A5 refillable journals
Our verdict“This refill is best for users who require high page volume and durable paper for daily or intensive writing tasks.”
SETTINI Refill Inserts for A5 Refillable Journal, 192 Pages, Lined
The SETTINI inserts feature 192 pages of acid-free, 100 gsm paper designed for writing, sketching, and planning. Compared with the Moonster A5 Lined Insert, it emphasizes sustainability with eco-friendly materials and acid-free quality, making it ideal for artists and mindful consumers. Its size fits the Settini Doppio Journal perfectly but limits use with non-compatible notebooks. The lined layout caters to writers and planners, but the absence of perforations or alternative paper types restricts flexibility for varied projects. This refill excels for those who value high-quality, environmentally responsible paper for creative and organizational purposes.
Pros:- High-quality, acid-free paper
- Eco-friendly and responsibly sourced
- Versatile size suitable for writing and sketching
Cons:- Designed specifically for A5 journals, limiting broader use
- No perforations or varied paper types for different needs
Best for: Eco-minded writers and sketchers who need a versatile, sustainable refill.
Not ideal for: Users seeking mixed media or perforated pages for easy removal or varied formats.
- Pages:192
- Paper Weight:100 gsm
- Color:Natural white
- Dimensions:8.5 x 5.5 inches
Our verdict“This refill is ideal for environmentally conscious users who want a durable, versatile paper for writing and sketching.”
Moonster A5 Journal Inserts Lined – Cotton Paper Refill for Leather Journal
The Moonster inserts stand out for their handcrafted cotton paper, offering a tactile woven texture and excellent fountain pen friendliness. Compared to the more standard kraft or acid-free papers, these are designed for artistic writing, doodling, or detailed lettering, fitting into refillable leather covers with ease. The 80 sheets—totaling 160 pages—may be less than other options like the Zhanmai or the 256-page refill, making them less suited for heavy daily use. The binding isn’t specified, which could impact durability over time, but the bleed-proof cotton paper makes them a favorite for creative users. This choice is best for artists or writers seeking a unique, tactile experience with fountain pens and elegant presentation.
Pros:- Eco-friendly, handcrafted cotton paper
- Fountain pen friendly with no bleed-through
- Beautiful woven texture and smooth surface
Cons:- Limited to 80 sheets, less capacity for daily use
- Binding type unspecified, may affect durability
Best for: Artists and calligraphy enthusiasts preferring handcrafted, bleed-proof cotton paper.
Not ideal for: Users needing high page volume or standard writing paper for everyday journaling.
- Material:Cotton paper
- Size:5.75″ x 8.25″
- Sheet Count:80 sheets / 160 pages
- Paper Weight:130gsm
Our verdict“This refill suits artistic writers and fountain pen users looking for a tactile, handcrafted experience.”
Moonster A5 Lined Journal Refill – 192 Pages, 120gsm, Built-in Bookmark
This refill offers 192 pages of premium 120gsm paper, ideal for smooth writing and travel journaling. Compared with the SETTINI refill, it emphasizes durability with thicker paper and includes a built-in bookmark for easy navigation, perfect for busy travelers or daily diary keepers. The high-quality paper minimizes bleed-through and feathering, but the fixed size and single format limit its adaptability for varied creative projects. Its built-in bookmark adds convenience, though it only fits A5-sized journals. This refill makes the most sense for those who prioritize high-quality paper and features like a bookmark for frequent travelers or daily writers.
Pros:- High-quality 120gsm paper for smooth writing
- Built-in bookmark for easy page tracking
- Durable construction suitable for travel
Cons:- Limited to A5 size, not universal for all journals
- Refill only, no standalone notebook
Best for: Travelers and daily journal users who value durability and convenient navigation.
Not ideal for: Creative users seeking varied formats or larger, more flexible refill options.
- Pages:192
- Paper Weight:120gsm
- Size:A5
- Includes:Built-in bookmark
Our verdict“This refill is perfect for travelers and daily journalers who want durable paper with added navigation features.”
The Amazing Office Journal Refill, College Ruled Lined Paper, 5.5×8.125 Inch Insert, Fits A5 Journals, 100 Sheets / 200 Pages
This refill stands out due to its compatibility with standard A5 journals and travelers notebooks, making it a flexible choice for those who switch between different covers. The high-quality 80 GSM paper resists bleed-through better than thinner options, which is a key advantage over cheaper refills like the Zhanmai 5 Pack, although it’s limited to college-ruled lines only—no options for blank or dotted pages. The sewn binding ensures pages lie flat, an essential feature for comfortable writing, especially compared with refills like the Wanderings A5 insert that offers more pages but less flexibility in binding. While easy to swap and lightweight, it does not include a cover, so users need to provide their own, and it only fits A5-sized journals, which could be a drawback for those with larger or smaller notebooks. Overall, this refill makes the most sense for users who prioritize quality, fit, and ease of use in an A5 format, but those looking for variety in line types or covers should consider other options.
Pros:- Fits standard A5 journals and travelers notebooks easily
- High-quality 80 GSM bleed-resistant paper
- Pages lie flat for comfortable writing
- Simple to swap in and out without fuss
Cons:- Limited to A5-sized journals, restricting size flexibility
- No cover included, requiring an additional purchase
- Only available in college-ruled lines, limiting style options
Best for: Individuals who frequently use A5 journals or travelers notebooks and want high-quality, bleed-resistant paper.
Not ideal for: Buyers needing blank, dotted, or specialty pages, or those looking for a refill with an included cover or larger sheet sizes.
- Size:5.5 x 8.125 inches
- Sheets:100 sheets
- Pages:200 pages
- Paper Weight:80 GSM
- Binding:Sewn
Our verdict“This refill is ideal for A5 journal users who prioritize quality and ease of use over line variety or included accessories.”
How We Picked
To evaluate these wish journal refill pages, I focused on factors that matter most to journal users: paper quality, size compatibility, page style, durability, and overall value. Each product was assessed for how well it fits various journal systems, whether the paper minimizes ink bleed and feathering, and if the quantity justifies the price. The ranking reflects a balance of affordability, quality, and versatility, ensuring options suit different types of wish journal users—from casual creators to serious planners. Products with consistent performance across these criteria earned higher positions, while tradeoffs like price or limited size options influenced lower rankings.Factors to Consider When Choosing Wish Journal Refill Pages
Choosing the right wish journal refill pages requires understanding key factors that affect your journaling experience. Size compatibility is essential, so verify that the refills fit your journal model. Paper quality impacts how your ink and markers behave—thicker, acid-free paper reduces bleed-through and extends the lifespan of your pages. Consider whether you prefer lined, blank, or specialized pages like grid or dotted, based on your writing or creative style. Price per sheet and total page count influence value, especially if you plan to journal frequently. Lastly, look at additional features such as built-in bookmarks or reinforced binding for longevity.Size Compatibility and Fit
Ensuring your refill pages match your journal’s dimensions is vital to avoid loose pages or difficulty fitting them. Measure your journal’s size precisely, noting if it’s A5, personal size, or another dimension. Some refills are designed for specific brands or systems, so double-check compatibility before purchasing. Opting for the wrong size can lead to frustration or wasted money, so prioritize accurate measurements and product descriptions.
Paper Quality and Thickness
The quality of paper greatly influences your journaling experience. Thicker paper, ideally 120gsm or higher, minimizes bleed-through when using pens, markers, or highlighter. Lower gsm paper may be more affordable but can cause ink to show through or feather, reducing readability. Consider your preferred writing tools and whether you want pages suitable for creative wishes with drawings or stickers, which demand sturdier paper.
Page Style and Layout
Deciding between lined, blank, dotted, or grid pages depends on your journaling style. Lined pages support structured wish writing, making it easier to organize thoughts, while blank pages offer flexibility for sketches or more freeform wishes. Dotted or grid pages can serve hybrid purposes, combining writing and drawing. Think about how you plan to use your wish journal and select a style that enhances your experience.
Quantity and Price Considerations
More pages often translate to better value, especially if you journal frequently. However, larger packs can be more expensive upfront, so calculate the price per sheet to compare options fairly. Also, consider whether the quantity aligns with your usage rate—buying in bulk makes sense if you plan to refill regularly, but it may be wasteful if your journaling is sporadic.
Additional Features and Durability
Some refills include extras like built-in bookmarks, reinforced edges, or perforated pages for easy removal. These features can extend the lifespan of your refills and improve usability. However, they might also add to the cost. Focus on what enhances your journaling experience without unnecessary extras that inflate the price or complicate the refill system.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will these refill pages fit my specific wish journal?
Most refill pages are designed for standard sizes like A5 or personal sizes, but compatibility varies by brand and system. Always check the product dimensions and your journal’s measurements before purchasing. If your journal uses a proprietary system, look for refills explicitly labeled as compatible or designed for that brand to ensure a proper fit. When in doubt, contact the seller or manufacturer for confirmation.
Can I use any pen or marker on these refill pages without bleed-through?
Not all paper is created equal in handling ink. Thicker, higher gsm paper reduces bleed-through and feathering, allowing you to use a variety of pens confidently. For heavy ink users, look for refills with 120gsm or more. Testing your preferred pens on a small area before writing extensively is advisable, especially if the paper quality isn’t specified clearly.
Are there refill pages suitable for creative wish journaling, like sketches or stickers?
Yes, blank or dotted refill pages are better suited for creative expressions such as sketches, stickers, or mixed media. These options provide a smooth surface and flexibility that lined pages may restrict. Be sure to select thicker paper if you plan to use markers or heavy media to prevent bleed-through and warping. Some brands also offer specialized art or craft refills for these purposes.
How many pages should I buy at once for regular journaling?
The ideal quantity depends on your journaling frequency. If you write daily, a pack with 192 or more pages ensures several months of use. For occasional journaling, smaller packs may suffice to avoid unused pages. Consider your budget, storage space, and how quickly you typically go through refills to determine a sustainable purchase size.
What is the best way to store or handle unused refill pages?
To keep your refill pages in good condition, store them flat in a dry, cool place away from direct sunlight. Use protective sleeves or binders to prevent bending or tearing. Handling pages with clean hands and avoiding excessive exposure to moisture will help maintain their quality, ensuring they remain pristine for when you need them.
Conclusion
For general users seeking a reliable and versatile refill, the Traveler Notebook Refills Insert – A5 Ruled offers a balanced mix of quality, size compatibility, and value, making it the best overall choice. Budget-conscious buyers will appreciate the Zhanmai 5 Pack A5 Notebook Inserts, which deliver decent quality at a lower cost. Those new to wish journaling should opt for the Moonster A5 Lined Journal Refill with its user-friendly design and generous pages, easing the learning curve. Finally, if you require specialized features like thicker paper or creative flexibility, consider premium options like the Wanderings A5 Lined Travelers Notebook Insert.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
